10 Famous Historic Ballet Rivalries

Behind ballet’s poised performances and polished pirouettes lies a rich history of backstage drama, spirited competition, and intense rivalries. Ballet dancers are artists and athletes and like all high performers, they thrive in environments that challenge and push them. Throughout history, some of ballet’s most iconic figures have found themselves in creative clashes – rivalries that not only stirred headlines but also raised the artistic bar. So, take a graceful leap into the world of ballet’s most famous rivalries, where elegance met intensity and legends were born.

1. Marie Taglioni vs. Fanny Elssler In the early 19th century, the ballet world was captivated by two women with vastly different styles: the ethereal Marie Taglioni and the fiery Fanny Elssler. Taglioni, known for her light, almost spiritual dancing, epitomised the Romantic ideal. Elssler, by contrast, was all grounded passion and flair – her performances of the Spanish-style cachucha were the stuff of legend. Audiences were divided and ballet lovers fiercely debated which style – and which star – was superior.

2. Margot Fonteyn vs. Moira Shearer British ballet was booming in the mid-20th century and two prima ballerinas led the charge. Margot Fonteyn, elegant and reserved, was the darling of The Royal Ballet, while Moira Shearer dazzled in film as well as on stage, famously starring in The Red Shoes. While the rivalry was more about public perception than personal feuds, it reflected a divide between classical purists and modern audiences embracing cinema’s influence on dance.

3. Rudolf Nureyev vs. Mikhail Baryshnikov Two of the greatest male dancers of all time, both defecting from the Soviet Union, both reshaping ballet for a global audience – of course comparisons were inevitable. Nureyev, wild and charismatic, brought raw intensity to his roles. Baryshnikov, technically flawless and artistically versatile, was ballet’s golden boy. Their styles differed, but both revolutionised male dancing and their overlapping careers made fans constantly debate who truly reigned supreme.

4. Natalia Makarova vs. Gelsey Kirkland In the 1970s, two powerful personalities defined American Ballet Theatre’s star power. Russian-born Natalia Makarova brought Soviet technique and dramatic flair, while American Gelsey Kirkland was known for her emotional depth and fragility. Tensions were rumoured behind the scenes as the two vied for leading roles and critical acclaim. Their rivalry, whether personal or performance-based, added fuel to the company’s dynamic golden era.

5. Anna Pavlova vs. Tamara Karsavina Pavlova and Karsavina were two of Imperial Russia’s finest exports, both luminaries of the Ballets Russes. Pavlova became a global icon with her portrayal of The Dying Swan, while Karsavina won acclaim for her dramatic power and range. Though they often danced together, including in Les Sylphides, subtle tension and artistic rivalry simmered beneath the surface, amplified by their contrasting temperaments and career paths.

6. Maya Plisetskaya vs. Galina Ulanova In Soviet ballet’s golden age, Galina Ulanova was the reigning queen – beloved by Stalin and idolised across the USSR. Enter Maya Plisetskaya: bold, modern and technically dazzling. Plisetskaya’s rise was seen as a challenge to Ulanova’s legacy. Though they reportedly had mutual respect, the media and political system fuelled comparisons and tension. Each had her moment in the spotlight, with distinct interpretations of roles like Juliet and Odette/Odile.

7. Sylvie Guillem vs. Traditional Ballet Standards This rivalry isn’t dancer vs. dancer, but dancer vs. institution. Sylvie Guillem broke rules and defied expectations throughout her career. With her extreme flexibility, sharp wit and unapologetic independence, she ruffled feathers in the traditionally rigid world of ballet. Her departure from The Royal Ballet and transition into contemporary work were viewed as rebellion – but also inspired a generation to think differently about what ballet could be.

8. Alicia Alonso vs. Western Recognition Alicia Alonso, Cuba’s ballet legend, built a world-class company in Havana despite political tensions and geographical isolation. Her “rival” wasn’t a single dancer, but rather the broader Western ballet world that often overlooked Latin American talent. Alonso’s determination, artistry and fierce defence of Cuban ballet carved out space for dancers from the Global South and earned her enduring international respect.

9. Alina Cojocaru vs. Tamara Rojo In the early 2000s, The Royal Ballet again saw two phenomenal women rise to fame. Romanian-born Alina Cojocaru was praised for her lyrical delicacy and crystalline technique. Spanish dynamo Tamara Rojo dazzled with passion and authority. Though they danced many of the same roles, their interpretations were worlds apart – leading to whispers of a quiet rivalry as both vied for the spotlight.

10. Margot Fonteyn vs. The Changing Guard at The Royal Ballet Margot Fonteyn is revered as one of the most graceful and beloved ballerinas in history, but even legends aren’t immune to backstage tensions. As she continued performing well into her 50s—especially during her celebrated partnership with Rudolf Nureyev—whispers grew among younger dancers at The Royal Ballet. Some felt that her prolonged time in the spotlight limited opportunities for rising talent and prevented the natural evolution of the company. While there was no dramatic fallout, the quiet discontent behind the scenes painted a picture of the challenges that come when a company must balance respect for a living legend with the need for artistic renewal. This gentle but poignant rivalry reminds us that even in the world of pointe shoes and pirouettes, change can be as complex as choreography.

The Art of Competition While rivalries can seem dramatic or even divisive, many have driven ballet to evolve, improve and expand. They push dancers to reach higher, challenge conventions and bring new dimensions to beloved roles. Some rivalries are personal, others purely artistic – but all leave a lasting impact on the art form.

Healthy Rivalry vs. Harmful Competition It’s important to remember that not all competition is negative. Healthy rivalry can foster innovation and excellence, as long as it’s grounded in mutual respect. Many of the dancers on this list, despite tensions, have expressed admiration for their so-called rivals.

Final Curtain Call Ballet may look effortless on stage, but behind the curtain, it’s often a tale of drive, ambition and creative conflict. From Romantic icons to modern disruptors, these rivalries have shaped ballet’s history and continue to inspire the next generation. Whether it’s a battle of styles, personalities, or philosophies, ballet’s greatest rivalries prove that even in a world built on beauty and balance, a little drama can go a long way.

You Might Also Like…